Fragments

IT’S HIS FIRST TIME TOO…

IT’S HIS FIRST TIME TOO…

IT’S HIS FIRST TIME TOO…

We forgive ourselves for learning as we go. Sometimes, we forget our parents were learning too.

We forgive ourselves for learning as we go. Sometimes, we forget our parents were learning too.

When I was ten, I thought my father was angry with me. When I was fifteen, I thought he didn't understand me. When I was twenty, I thought he was disappointed in me. But, somewhere in my thirties, I began to wonder if perhaps, all those years he had simply been afraid. Afraid that his son, would suffer in this world if he did not prepare him well enough.

I wish I had thought of that sooner.

But children rarely understand that their parents are afraid. To a child, a father isn't supposed to be afraid. He is the man who knows. He knows which road to take when you are lost. He knows what to say to the mechanic. He knows how much something should cost. He knows when you are lying. He knows what you should study. What you should become. How much you should save. What time you should come home.

At least, that's what I thought.

My father had an answer for everything. When you're young, certainty can sound a lot like anger. As a boy, I wanted his approval for everything. A good mark. A medal. A family member or teacher saying something nice about me. I would carry these little victories home like offerings.

Look, Papa. Look what I did. Look who I am becoming. Sometimes he was proud. Sometimes he would ask why I hadn't done better. I remembered the second kind more.

Children are strange that way. A hundred quiet acts of love can disappear behind one sentence that hurt. I didn't see the school fees. I didn't see the bills. I didn't see the calculations made after I had gone to sleep. I didn't see the things he didn't buy for himself because there was something I wanted.

I saw the face across the table asking why ninety wasn't ninety-five. I thought, Nothing I do will ever be enough for him.

By thirteen, frustration had found a voice. Why couldn't he just say he was proud of me? Why did every achievement become a lesson? Why did every mistake become a warning about my future? Why did everything have to be about discipline? I would watch other fathers laugh with their sons and wonder why mine couldn't be like that. Of course, I only ever saw those fathers for a few minutes. I saw mine every day.

Comparison has always been unfair like that. We compare the entirety of the people we love with the fragments other people allow us to see. I didn't know that then. I only knew that my friends seemed to have fathers who understood them. I had a father who seemed determined to prepare me for some terrible examination called life.

[[DIVIDER]]

Then I became a teenager. Frustration became anger. I stopped wanting his approval. Or at least, that is what I told myself.

I wanted to make my own decisions. He wanted me to think about consequences. I wanted freedom. He wanted responsibility. I wanted him to trust me. He wanted me to give him reasons to. Neither of us knew how to translate.

So love began arriving disguised as arguments.

“Where are you going?” Was actually - I worry about you.
“What time will you be back?” Was actually - Come home safe.
“Why do you need this?” Was actually - I want you to understand the value of money.
“What are you going to do with your life?” Was actually - I need to know you'll be all right when I'm no longer the one taking care of you.

But I couldn't hear any of that. I only heard the questions.
Every question sounded like - I don't trust you.

[[DIVIDER]]

By my early twenties, the anger had changed again. It became sadness. That was worse.

Because anger still believes there is something worth fighting about. Sadness begins to accept things. I began to believe that perhaps I simply wasn't the son he had imagined. He had built himself from almost nothing. He had worked until his name meant something. I was standing beneath everything he had built, wondering how I was supposed to build something taller.

I loved being his son. I hated being his shadow. Both things were true at the same time.

I had dreams larger than my salary. I wanted things I had not yet earned. I wanted independence while still having to depend on him. I wanted him to believe in me before I had given him enough evidence that he should.

Whenever I sat across from him, I thought I saw disappointment in his eyes. Perhaps it was there. Perhaps some of it was mine. I no longer know. That's the cruelty of memory. We remember how someone looked at us, but rarely how we were looking at ourselves when they did.

Once, when I was young, someone asked what I wanted to be when I grew up. Other children had answers. Doctor. Engineer. Pilot. I apparently wanted to become an Olympic swimmer. Children should be forgiven for ambition. But there was another answer I remember more clearly. I wanted to be like my father. Years later, I would write to him that I was sorry I hadn't become the man he wanted me to be. I meant it.

I believed I had failed some invisible examination he had been conducting my entire life. I thought he had spent years measuring me against the man he expected his son to become. It took me much longer to realise that I had been measuring myself against him too. He wasn't the only one holding the ruler.

[[DIVIDER]]

And then, somewhere in my thirties, something changed. Not him. Me.

I began to reach the ages at which some of my earliest memories of him had been formed. That is a strange thing nobody warns you about. One day you realise your parents weren't always old.

They weren't born knowing how mortgages worked. They weren't born knowing how to raise children. They weren't born patient. Or wise. Or certain. There was once a version of my father who was younger than I am now. A man trying to build a career. Trying to build a home. Trying to be a husband. Trying to become something from nothing.

Somewhere in the middle of figuring out his own life, someone handed him a son. There was no manual. No rehearsal. No previous attempt from which he could learn. I had spent years judging his performance without once considering that it was his first time on the stage.

Maybe he was too strict sometimes. Maybe there were words he should not have said. Maybe there were moments when I needed encouragement and received instruction instead. Maybe there were days when I needed my father to put his hand on my shoulder and say,

I'm proud of you.
But he didn't.

Growing older does not require me to pretend those moments never happened. Understanding someone does not mean rewriting your childhood to make them perfect.

My father wasn't perfect. Neither am I.

That is precisely the point. I spent so many years forgiving myself with explanations.

I was young.
I didn't know better.
I was scared.
I was figuring things out.
It was the first time I had ever gone through something like that.

Then one day I realised how rarely I had offered my parents the same mercy.

It was their first life too.

My father had never been my father before. He had never raised this particular stubborn, ambitious, emotional, impossible boy before. He didn't know which sentences I would remember twenty years later. He didn't know which criticism would make me work harder and which one I would carry quietly into adulthood. He didn't know that sometimes his silence would become louder in my head than his words.

He didn't know. How could he? Neither did I and I still don’t.

We were both meeting each other for the first time. I was learning how to be a son. He was learning how to be a father. The only difference was that I was allowed to make mistakes because I was growing up. Somehow, I had forgotten that he was growing too.

Today, when I look at my father, I no longer see the impossible man whose shoes I was supposed to fill. They were never my shoes. I have my own. Perhaps that was something both of us needed time to understand. I don't need to become him to prove that he raised me well. I don't need his life to validate mine. I don't need to erase the things that hurt me in order to recognise everything he gave me.

The roof. The opportunities. The ridiculous things I wanted. The education. The second chances. The safety of knowing that however loudly we fought, there was still somewhere I could come home to. Perhaps most importantly, the standard I spent half my life resenting because I didn't yet understand what it was made of. He wanted me to stand on my own feet.

I thought that meant he couldn't wait to stop holding me. Now I wonder whether he was simply trying to make sure I could stand when one day he no longer could. There are things I wish my father had done differently. I'm sure there are things he wishes he had done differently too. There are certainly things I wish I had done differently as his son.

But maybe love, after enough years, stops keeping score. Maybe growing up isn't the moment you finally prove your parents wrong. Maybe it is the moment you finally see them as another human being. Not Father. Not Mother. Just a HUMAN.

People who were young once. People who were frightened. People who made decisions without knowing how those decisions would look twenty years later. People who sometimes confused protection with control. People who sometimes expressed fear as anger. People who loved us using whatever language of love they themselves had been taught. People who got things wrong. Just like us. So forgive your parents for the things you think they did wrong while raising you.

Not because those things didn't hurt. Not because parents are automatically right. Definitely not because being someone's child means you owe them absolution.

Forgive them because, eventually, you may realise something painfully simple.

It was their first life too. Probably their first time being a parent too.

While you were growing up, so were they.

[[DIVIDER]]

FOR EVERY SON WHO STRUGGLED TO SAY IT AND EVERY FATHER WHO STRUGGLED TO HEAR IT

[[DIVIDER]]

Dear Papa,

There is so much I have always wanted to tell you. But, finding the words to tell you how I feel has never been easy for me. So, I am writing them down.

I love you, more than I can express.

When I was younger, I saw you only as my father. The man who was supposed to know everything, solve everything, provide everything and somehow always know what was right. It took me all these years to finally see the man behind my father.

You were figuring it out too. You were building a life, a family, a business, a name. You started from nothing, you gave me more than anyone ever could. You loved me, looked after me, took care of me, provided for me, supported me and fulfilled wishes that, as I once admitted myself, were whimsical at best.

I don't think I understood what all of that cost you. I do now. But I cannot truly understand everything you had to go through.

I have always been proud of the fact that I am your son. When I was a boy and people asked me what I wanted to become, I wanted to grow up to be like my father.

I don't want to fill your shoes anymore, Papa. I finally understand that they were never mine to fill.

I want to walk beside you in my own. You don't have to carry everything alone anymore.

You have spent your life taking care of me. Let me take some of the weight now. Share the burden with me. You don't always have to be the man who has the answer, the man who fixes everything, the man who silently carries whatever needs to be carried.

You have a son. Let me be one.

I still have a lot to learn. I still have things to prove, perhaps most of all to myself. But one day, I will make you proud of the man I became.

Until then, I hope you know that I am already proud of the man you are.

I hope, somewhere beneath all the things we have never been very good at saying to each other, you love me even half as much as I love you.

Because that would still be more than enough.

Always your loving son.

false

– The Monark

Cinematic artwork showing two pairs of shoes, one older and one younger, placed side by side at a sunlit doorway, symbolising a father and son learning to walk through life in their own shoes.

SHARE THIS WRITING

SPEAK TO THE HOUSE

Have something to say? The House is listening.

Selected words may be preserved within the House.

SPEAK TO THE HOUSE

Have something to say? The House is listening.

Selected words may be preserved within the House.

SPEAK TO THE HOUSE

Have something to say? The House is listening.

Selected words may be preserved within the House.